Who Makes Health Care Decisions If You Can’t?

In the realm of healthcare, it is essential to have a plan in place for situations where an individual is unable to make their own medical decisions. There may be instances where a person is incapacitated due to a severe illness, a medical emergency, or being in a comatose state. In such circumstances, it becomes crucial to determine who has the authority to make healthcare decisions when an individual is unable to do so themselves. It is also very important to document your wishes with an experienced estate planning attorney.


In life, unexpected circumstances can arise, leaving individuals unable to make their own healthcare decisions. It is important to plan ahead and establish a framework for such situations. This article aims to provide insights into who makes healthcare decisions when an individual is unable to do so themselves.

Understanding the importance of healthcare decision-making

Healthcare decision-making plays a critical role in ensuring that individuals receive appropriate medical treatment and care. It involves choices about various aspects of healthcare, such as treatment options, medications, surgeries, and end-of-life care. When an individual becomes incapacitated, having a clear plan in place ensures that their wishes are respected and that decisions are made in their best interests.

Advance directives and their significance

Definition of advance directives

Advance directives are legal documents that allow individuals to express their healthcare preferences in advance. These directives guide medical professionals and appointed representatives when making decisions on behalf of an incapacitated individual.

Types of advance directives

There are several types of advance directives, including living wills and durable power of attorney for healthcare. A living will outlines specific medical treatments an individual would like to receive or avoid, while a durable power of attorney appoints a healthcare proxy to make decisions on their behalf.

Importance of creating advance directives

Creating advance directives is crucial to ensure that an individual’s healthcare preferences are honored, even if they cannot communicate their wishes at a later stage. It provides peace of mind and clarity for both the individual and their loved ones during challenging times.

estate planning attorney

Designating a healthcare proxy

Definition of a healthcare proxy

A healthcare proxy, also known as a healthcare agent or surrogate, is an individual designated to make healthcare decisions on behalf of an incapacitated person. This proxy is chosen by the individual and should be someone they trust implicitly to make decisions aligned with their wishes.

Role and responsibilities of a healthcare proxy

A healthcare proxy has the responsibility to act in the best interests of the incapacitated individual, based on their known wishes or values. They consult with medical professionals, gather information, and make decisions that align with the individual’s preferences.

Selecting a trustworthy healthcare proxy

When selecting a healthcare proxy, it is crucial to choose someone who understands and respects the individual’s values, beliefs, and treatment preferences. This person should be willing to advocate for the individual’s wishes and make decisions without imposing their personal opinions.

Legal guardianship and healthcare decisions

Definition of legal guardianship

Legal guardianship is a legal process that grants an individual the authority to make healthcare decisions for another person who is deemed incapable of doing so themselves. It is usually sought when advance directives and healthcare proxies are not in place.

Process of obtaining legal guardianship

To obtain legal guardianship, an interested party must petition the court and provide evidence of the individual’s incapacity. The court then determines whether guardianship is necessary and appoints a guardian who assumes the responsibility of making healthcare decisions.

Responsibilities and limitations of a legal guardian

A legal guardian is responsible for making decisions related to healthcare, personal welfare, and financial matters for the incapacitated person. They must act in the individual’s best interests and report to the court regularly. However, the court may limit the guardian’s decision-making powers based on the specific circumstances.

The role of family members in healthcare decisions

Involvement of immediate family members

Immediate family members, such as spouses, parents, and adult children, often play a significant role in healthcare decision-making. They are typically consulted and considered when determining the best course of action for the incapacitated individual.

Decision-making hierarchy among family members

In cases where there is no advance directive or appointed healthcare proxy, the decision-making hierarchy among family members varies by jurisdiction. Typically, spouses have priority, followed by adult children, parents, and siblings. The hierarchy ensures that decisions are made by individuals with the closest relationship to the incapacitated person.

Considering the best interests of the patient

Family members must make decisions that prioritize the best interests of the patient. This involves considering the individual’s previously expressed wishes, values, and quality of life. It is crucial to engage in open and honest communication among family members to reach a consensus on healthcare decisions.

Medical ethics and healthcare decision-making

Principles of medical ethics

Healthcare decision-making is guided by ethical principles such as autonomy, beneficence, and non-maleficence. Autonomy recognizes an individual’s right to make decisions about their own healthcare. Beneficence focuses on promoting the well-being of the patient, while non-maleficence emphasizes avoiding harm.

Balancing patient autonomy and beneficence

In situations where an individual cannot make their own decisions, healthcare professionals strive to balance patient autonomy with beneficence. They respect the wishes and values expressed in advance directives or by the appointed healthcare proxy, while ensuring that decisions are medically appropriate and beneficial.

Ethical considerations in end-of-life decisions

End-of-life decisions often raise complex ethical considerations. Healthcare providers, in collaboration with family members and ethical committees, evaluate the appropriateness of treatments, pain management, and the withdrawal or continuation of life-sustaining interventions. The aim is to ensure the highest quality of care and respect for the patient’s dignity.

The role of healthcare professionals

Collaboration with healthcare providers

Healthcare professionals play a crucial role in facilitating healthcare decision-making when an individual is unable to do so. They provide guidance, support, and medical expertise to both the appointed healthcare proxy and family members involved in the decision-making process.

Respecting the patient’s wishes and values

Healthcare professionals have a duty to respect the patient’s previously expressed wishes and values. They ensure that the decisions made align with the individual’s beliefs and preferences while providing appropriate medical care and treatment options.

Providing guidance and support

Healthcare professionals offer guidance and support to the appointed healthcare proxy and family members, explaining medical procedures, treatment options, and potential outcomes. They help navigate complex medical information, empowering decision-makers to make informed choices.


In conclusion, when it comes to healthcare decision-making in situations where an individual is unable to express their own preferences, having a comprehensive plan is crucial. By creating advance directives, designating a trusted healthcare proxy, and involving family members, individuals can ensure that their healthcare wishes are respected and upheld.

Navigating the complex legal and ethical landscape of healthcare decision-making may require the expertise of professionals well-versed in estate planning, such as Safe Harbor Estate Law estate planning attorneys. These attorneys possess the knowledge and experience to guide individuals through the process of creating advance directives, establishing legal guardianship if necessary, and ensuring that all legal requirements are met.

The collaboration between healthcare professionals, appointed healthcare proxies, and estate planning attorneys can provide a solid framework for making healthcare decisions on behalf of incapacitated individuals. It ensures that medical treatments align with the individual’s wishes, values, and quality of life.

In times of vulnerability and uncertainty, having a well-thought-out plan for healthcare decision-making brings peace of mind to both individuals and their loved ones. By taking proactive steps and seeking guidance from professionals like Safe Harbor Estate Law estate planning attorneys, individuals can navigate the complexities of healthcare decision-making and ensure their wishes are honored when they need it most.

Remember, proactive planning is key. So, take the necessary steps today to protect your future and secure your healthcare decisions.